After extensive discussion about Querida Amazonia, the strategy team and advisors of Catholic Church Reform Int’l have moved from passionate disappointment in Pope Francis to a realization that it not his style to make a papal decree about such critical matters as married priesthood and the role of women. The church he is advocating is a synodal church, i.e. one that walks together. 

“I think the pope is looking for a deeper change,” said Fr. Joe Healey, our associate in Nigeria. “He wants us to move away from that monarchical model and engage the whole church in the process of discernment on issues like bringing back the female diaconate. You can't achieve synodality if you continually look to the pope to make the tough calls.

The following article was written by freelance Brazilian journalist, Luis Miguel Modino

Sister Roselei Bertoldo receives international recognition

See also

Catholic Church Reform International, a global network with more than a hundred groups, with supporters in 65 countries, its headquarters in the United States, has recognized Sister Roselei Bertoldo for her tireless work in the struggle for reform, especially in confronting human trafficking and gender equality in the Catholic Church.

Following the doctrine of the Second Vatican Council, which has been taken up by Pope Francis, this organization is striving to make a new way of being Church a reality, an increasingly necessary dimension given the current situation that society and the Catholic Church are experiencing, with constant attacks by groups that want to take the Church back to the pre-conciliar mode.

The CCRI network, which is based on interaction and collaboration of the different groups and individuals who are part of the organization, is striving to make a Church based on love rather than on laws. As this group interacts with people from around the globe, the goal is to make the lived experience within the church community more inclusive and welcoming for everyone.

On the night of January 23 in João Pessoa, Kathleen Bond, a Maryknoll Lay Missioner, presented the plaque as CCRI's only second-ever honoree to Sr. Rosele Bertoldo, in recognition of her work.

Sr. Roselei (on right) receiving CCRI honoree award from Maryknoll lay missioner, Kathleen Bond (on left)

Sister Roselei of the Congregation of the Sisters of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, who has been working in the Amazon since February 2012, was one of the auditors at the assembly of the Synod for the Amazon, which took place in Rome from October 6 to 27, 2019. This synod has been considered by many as a moment of great importance within the process of ecclesial reform. In fact, the voices of women and indigenous people were assessed as a fundamental element in the debates developed throughout the synod process.

The fight against human trafficking, a dimension present in the synodal reflection, gathered in the final document of the Synod for the Amazon, is one of the major problems present in Pan-Amazon, one of the many wounds that hurt the peoples of the region, especially the most vulnerable such as women and children. The work developed by Rede um Grito pela Vida, of which Rose Bertoldo is part, has been a strong boost in combating and creating awareness both within and without the Catholic Church.

According to Sister Rose Bertoldo, "It is with great gratitude that I received this award, an acknowledgment for the work that the Um Grito pela Vida Network has been carrying out over these years, especially in the whole process of preparation for the synodal assembly in the Church of the Amazon. We have taken significant steps in caring for life, a long process of articulation and formation of leaders in many ecclesial spaces. This has contributed to the Church beginning to assume as a mission the defense of the lives of people who are victims of abuse, sexual exploitation, and human trafficking in persons."

Sr. Roselei's experience of being an auditor at the Amazonian Synod

Sister Roselei Bertoldo, ICM, works to combat human trafficking in the Amazon region of Brazil and attended the Synod on the Amazon in Rome, October 6-27, 2019. This article was first published on the Maryknoll Office for Global concerns website.

I write a few lines in an attempt to describe the synodal process, which began in Porto Maldonado in October 2017, when Pope Francis announced the Special Synod for the Amazon, with the theme New Paths for Synodal Energy.

Being part of the Synod process was an immense gift. I was able to participate in the preparatory phase, including the assemblies and series of conversations and seminars with people from the Amazon region. I read the reports of the Regional Norte 1 preparatory gatherings, which included dialogue with nine dioceses and prelatures. Studying this immense wealth of experience made me aware of the extent of the wounded lives, the destruction experienced by so many communities, and the pain caused by a system of death that puts profit above life.

It was also beautiful to learn about the resistance to that culture of death, the concern for all life, and the many initiatives for the care for our common home from the peoples of the Amazon. For them, there is no separation between the land and life itself. The working document for the Synod, Laboris Instrumentum, was a synthesis of the voices of the more than 87,000 people who participated in the preparatory listening process in the pan-Amazonian region.

A Time of Grace

It was also a gift to participate in the Synod itself in Rome as an auditor. The Synod made me believe that we are living in a time of grace. The three-week meeting was a fruitful time in which participants were guided by the Spirit revealed in the little things of everyday life. I carried with me all of the voices and realities of the people who participated in the preparatory process in the Amazon region.

Pope Francis was present during the whole Synod, listening carefully to the many stories shared and ideas put forth based on the realities in the Amazon. At various times, when there seemed to be no clarity in the dialogue, the pope contributed simple insights that indicated the way forward. It was a long process of listening, built by many hands, a process of dialogue and walking together.

In this journey together, the presence of indigenous peoples and women made a difference. Their deep and powerful interventions in the assembly were often demonstrations of resistance, indignation, and celebration, interwoven with chanting and applause. The Latin, feminine way of being church drew the attention of all participants.

The twelve or so small working groups of the Synod, organized by language, were where participants clarified points and explored more deeply ideas that had been articulated in the large session. There was a greater freedom of expression and more time for participants to speak in the small groups than in the large assembly. These small groups greatly contributed to the proposals in the final document presented to the Synod Fathers and the pope on the last day of the meeting.

Invitation to Conversion

The final document organized the proposals into five chapters: Amazon: From listening to integral conversion; New paths of pastoral conversion; New paths of cultural conversion; New ecological conversion paths; New synodal conversion paths.

The invitation to conversion permeates the final document because "without conversions there are no new paths." We are invited to an integral conversion, which translates into "a simple and sober life" on a personal and community level. The Church is committed to being allied with the indigenous populations, the text repeats, especially in condemning attacks on their lives. The final document makes clear that the Church stands with the people.

Participation of Women

A special highlight was the participation of the 36 women at the Synod. We made significant contributions, weaving together threads from the small working groups and large assembly. I believe it would not have been the same if we had not been in that Synod room. In addition to clear, firm, strong interventions, full of prophetic witness, we made many contributions in the small working groups, in the presence of the synod priests and among ourselves, articulating thoughts as only those who do not conform to established structures can do.

We women made great strides. We may not be able to translate what they all mean right now, but we are sure that we have left a legacy for future generations by opening new paths to a church with a feminine and feminist face, a church that builds and grows, so that we have communities that take care of life and our common home.

Change begins with each of us

Pope Francis defined the Synod on the Amazon as the offspring of Laudato Si, the document which set forth our need for ecological conversion to address an ecological crisis so profound that if we do not change course, we will continue down a path to destruction. Change begins with each of us.

While the Synod was taking place in Rome, REPAM (Network for the Pan-Amazon Region) organized more than 240 events and exhibits as part of the "Tent for Our Common Home" in the Church of Traspontina, near St Peter's Basilica, and at local universities and other spaces where indigenous people and others attending and interested in the Synod can meet to pray and share about the reality of the Amazon. Check out Amazon:Common Home. Many people participated, including the Indigenous Missionary Council, or CIMI, a committee of the Brazilian bishops' conference, NGOs, religious congregations, and many indigenous peoples.

With the conclusion of the Synod, we now begin what is perhaps the slowest and deepest process, which is to put into practice the recommendations of the Synod. This requires that we walk together, change our mentality, and build new pathways in a society and church that is diverse and plural, and that seeks to protect life and promote integral ecology.

I extend enormous gratitude to Pope Francis, and also to the women with whom I shared these 21 days of the Synod. There was much synergy, which was a deep learning experience for me. We exchanged our experiences and knowledge in a profound expression of faith and hope. Each person left a mark on this process of understanding that the sacredness of life extends much farther than we previously believed and that we are the great generators and caregivers of life and earth, our common home.

As I contemplate this journey, I reaffirm the prophetic dimension of women's lives as a collective, of our feminine / feminist being, and of the need for and depth of our walk, hand in hand for peace and justice, for the care for integral ecology, because we do not separate any of it from our lives.

Cry of hope of the Church

I conclude with the words Pope Francis spoke in his homily during the Amazon Synod closing Mass:

"In this Synod we have had the grace of listening to the voices of the poor and reflecting on the precariousness of their lives, threatened by predatory models of development. And yet, precisely in this situation, many have witnessed to us that it is possible to look at reality differently, welcoming it with open hands as a gift, dwelling in creation, not as a means to be explored, but as a house to be guarded, trusting in God. He is a Father and, says Ben Sirá, 'will hear the prayer of the oppressed' (35:13)."

"How many times, even in the Church, have the voices of the poor not been heard and perhaps scoffed at or silenced because they are inconvenient," the pope said. "Let us pray for the grace to be able to listen to the cry of the poor: this is the cry of hope of the Church. When we make their cry our own, our prayer, too, will reach to the clouds."

International Women's Day March 8, 2020

The newly formed Catholic Women's Council together with the German Movement Maria 2.0 and Voices of Faith is proposing marking International Women's Day on 8 March 2020 with groups wearing white scarves / white ribbons / or white clothes. All are encouraged to take part in this action. Click this link for more details and listings of those already set up in different cities. If you or your organization would be interested in organizing such an event in your city, contact This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Your donations and contributions of ideas are most appreciated

Grateful to all for your donations and This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. It is beyond time that we rise up and shout out that women must be recognized as equals in the Catholic Church.

Rene Reid
CCRI, director

Clerical Sex Abuse Scandal Despite the slowness of reforming our Church, some changes are beginning to take place. No doubt, the entire year has been overshadowed by the clergy sex abuse scandal. Tribunals are slowly being established in dioceses around the globe though only headed by laity in not-nearly-enough instances. We're happy to see Francis lift the papal secrecy rule on this abuse. Follow Australia's lead, New Zealand implemented own Royal Commission to investigate this matter. So far, 1400 victims have come forward to talk to the Commission. The members plan to have a temporary report out by the end of 2020 and the final by 2023. There is talk among the laity of this also leading to a Plenary Council for this country.

You are invited to become an active member of CCRI Whether you are a former Catholic no longer affiliated with the institutional Church, or appalled by the clerical sex abuse crisis, feeling excluded due to being divorced and remarried, a young adult who feels that your life issues are not being addressed by the church, wanting something more than just Sunday church, or someone who is seeking a more personal community, we hope that you join us in one or both of two ways that may enhance your own faith experience in today's world.